Hardwood vs. Luxury Vinyl Plank: Which Holds Up Better in Denton Homes?
For most Denton, TX homes, luxury vinyl plank (LVP) holds up better than solid hardwood due to its waterproof core and tolerance for the area's expansive clay soil and humidity swings. Solid hardwood still wins on resale prestige and long-term refinishing potential in homes with stable, well-settled foundations.
Quick Comparison
Durability Against Moisture
LVP is 100% waterproof, making it ideal for Denton's storm-heavy spring months and for households with kids or pets. Solid hardwood can warp, cup, or stain if exposed to standing water or sustained humidity, which is a real risk during DFW's wetter stretches.
Performance on Shifting Foundations
Because LVP floats over the subfloor, it tolerates the minor seasonal movement common in homes built on Denton County's expansive clay soil. Solid hardwood, nailed or glued directly to the subfloor, is more likely to show gapping or buckling if the slab shifts.
Look and Feel
High-end LVP today closely mimics real wood grain and texture, but solid hardwood still offers a depth and warmth that's hard to fully replicate, along with the ability to be sanded and refinished multiple times over decades.
Cost
LVP is typically less expensive both in material and installation than solid hardwood, and it generally has a lower lifetime cost since it doesn't require periodic refinishing.
When Hardwood Still Makes Sense in Denton
Established homes in older, settled neighborhoods with no history of foundation movement are good candidates for solid hardwood, particularly in formal living areas and primary bedrooms where moisture exposure is minimal. If resale value and a premium, timeless look are top priorities, hardwood remains a strong investment.
When LVP Is the Smarter Choice
- Newer construction homes in Denton County still experiencing initial slab settlement (Stark Farms, Old North Park, and similar communities).
- Households with pets, kids, or higher foot traffic.
- Kitchens, mudrooms, and other moisture-prone areas.
- Homeowners who want a wood look on a tighter budget.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I install LVP over existing hardwood in a Denton home?
In most cases, yes, as long as the existing hardwood is flat, stable, and free of significant damage. A flooring professional should evaluate the subfloor first.
Does LVP lower home resale value compared to hardwood?
High-quality LVP is well accepted by Denton-area buyers today and is not typically viewed as a downgrade, especially in kitchens, bathrooms, and main living spaces. Hardwood still carries a slight premium in formal areas for some buyers.
Still Deciding? We Can Help
Simmons Floor Covering installs both hardwood and LVP throughout Denton and the surrounding communities. Bring us your floor plan and we'll tell you honestly which option fits your home and budget.
From shopping to purchasing to a professional installation, the Pro’s at Simmons Floor Covering will work with you focusing on all the details and committed to exceeding your expectations.
Simmons Floor Covering
400 N. Loop 288 Suite 104
Denton, TX 76209
940-341-2740